Official website of the City and County of Honolulu
  You are here:  Main / Ethics Commission / Meeting Information / August 30, 2005 EC Mtg Minutes






Date and Place:     August 30, 2005

                             Standard Financial Plaza

                             Conference Room, Suite 211


Present:                 Robin D. Liu, Chair

                             Lex R. Smith, Vice Chair

                             Susan S. Heitzman

                             Raymond H. Fujii

                             Matthew H. Kobayashi

                             Wayne T. Hikida

                             Charles W. Totto, Executive Director and Legal Counsel (EDLC)

                             Matthew J. Viola, Outside Counsel

Stenographer:        Norm Fisher 


I.          CALL TO ORDER


            The 387th meeting of the Ethics Commission (Commission or EC) was called to order at 11:30 a.m. by the Chair.





            The minutes of the open meeting of July 25, 2005, were unanimously approved.




A.        Confirming the date and time of the September 27, 2005 meeting and setting the date and time for the October 2005 meeting


            The EC rescheduled the September 27 meeting to September 28, 2005 at 11:30 a.m. and set the date and time for the October 18, 2005 at 11:30 a.m. meeting in the Standard Financial Plaza Conference Room, Suite 211.




A.        Administrative news


            The Executive Director and Legal Counsel (EDLC) referred to his memorandum dated August 30, 2005, outlining the total amount of web site hits and ethics training conducted in fiscal year 2006.


             B.              Report on Bill 52 (2005) for the transfer of regulation of lobbyists from the Council to the Ethics 

             The EDLC reported that he met with Council Chair Dela Cruz and Executive Matters Committee Chair Charles Djou who support the bill.  The EDLC stated that Bill 52 (2005) will be heard beginning in September 2005.


C.        Election of new officers


The EDLC reported that the EC usually elects the Chair and Vice Chair in the first quarter of each calendar year. 


            The EC moved, seconded, and unanimously carried to maintain the current Chair and Vice Chair until December 31, 2005.


 D.       COGEL Conference

            The EDLC reported that the 2005 COGEL Conference will be held in Boston from December 4 through 7.  The EDLC stated that based on current estimates, the EC should be able to send 4 people. 


The EC approved the attendance of Commissioners Lex Smith, Ray Fujii, Wayne Hikida, and the EDLC, Chuck Totto, to the 2005 COGEL Conference.


E.               Charter amendment clarifying that the Department of Corporation Counsel does not have the authority to withhold or transfer money from the ECís budget or control personnel actions

The EDLC reported that the fourth and final issue in the ECís packet to the Charter Commission is one that will help assure that the Commissionís budget is protected from raids by Corporation Counsel (COR), or a reduction by the Council or administration based on political motives.


The EDLC reported that it is clear that the framers of the Charter intended that the EC would be free of budgetary interference from COR.  However, from time-to-time COR has taken funds from the EC.  The EDLC stated that the Department of Budget and Fiscal Services (BFS) sanctions this because it considers the EC to be a division of COR rather than an independent agency. 


The EDLC stated that in FY2003 through 2005, the EC budget was pressured in several ways.  First, COR withheld or took back some funds. Second, the administration stated that any increase to the EC budget would have to come out of CORís budget.  Third, COR reviewed and approved or disapproved each expenditure and personnel action.


The EDLC stated that under the Charter, the Commission is attached to COR ďfor administrative purposes only.Ē  However, ďadministrative purposesĒ are not defined in the law, but include operational items such as payroll, purchasing services and goods, tracking funds and expenses and the like.  The EDLC stated that the BFS personnel (including the past 2 directors) who control the EC budget lump the EC in with COR for budget purposes.  The EDLC stated that the EC has also been subjected to across-the-board budget cuts by the administration.

            The EDLC stated that the staff recommends that the EC ask the Charter Commission to consider a Charter amendment that sets forth: (1) the independence of the EC; (2) clarifies that the EC, not COR has control over the Commissionís budget and personnel actions; and (3) sets forth the applicable minimum budget for the Commission. 


            The EDLC stated that this approach is also easily modified to drop any of the three components, should the Charter Commission wish to do so.  The EDLC stated that this proposal will have to be reviewed by COR for legality on behalf of the EC and the Charter Commission and suggests doing this within the next two weeks.


            After discussion, the EC moved, seconded, and unanimously carried to adopt the staffís recommendation, adding that the EDLC first take the budget and personnel issues to BFS and COR to try to work out a mutual agreement on an approach for the Charter amendment.




A.        Approval of the minutes of the executive session of the July 25, 2005 meeting

The minutes of the executive session of July 25, 2005 were unanimously approved.


B.                 Annual performance review of the Executive Director and Legal Counsel


The EC Chair appointed Commissioner Ray Fujii to prepare a draft performance review of the EDLC for the ECís review and discussion at the September 28, 2005 EC meeting.


            The EC moved, seconded, and unanimously carried to return to the open session.




            The EC moved, seconded, and unanimously carried to adjourn the meeting.  The meeting was adjourned at 12:10 p.m.

Last Reviewed: Tuesday, August 01, 2006