Council Bills and Resolutions Status

DATA FOR THIS RECORD AS OF 12/17/01

Resolution 98-265
Introduced: 09/28/98 by: JOHN HENRY FELIX=DUKE BAINUM
Re: SMP/SSV--WAIKIKI WAR MEMORIAL & NATATORIUM RESTORATION
97/SMA-25. 97/SV-2. DUKE BAINUM. JOHN HENRY FELIX. NATATORIUM. SHORELINE SETBACK VARIANCE. SPECIAL MANAGEMENT AREA.
Present status: Adopted 12/02/98

Title:
RESOLUTION GRANTING A SPECIAL MANAGEMENT AREA USE PERMIT AND SHORELINE SETBACK VARIANCE FOR PROPOSED RESTORATION OF THE WAIKIKI WAR MEMORIAL AND NATATORIUM.

Gist:

Resolution History:

12/02/98 COUNCIL ADOPT
Resolution adopted.

BAINUM, DUKE Y
DESOTO, JOHN Y
FELIX, JOHN HENRY Y
HANNEMANN, MUFI Y
HOLMES, STEVE N
KIM, DONNA MERCADO N
MANSHO, RENE Y
MIRIKITANI, ANDY Y
YOSHIMURA, JON N

Related Communications:

CC 379, 1998 by: DONNA MERCADO KIM
Reuqesting that Resolutions 98-319 and 98-265 be removed from the Committee on Zoning and placed on the Council's 12/02/98 agenda for consideration.

CC 381, 1998 by: JOHN HENRY FELIX
Informing Councilmembers that he will move for the adoption of the attached Findings of Fact.

CC 383, 1998 by: DONNA MERCADO KIM
Advising Council that the Findings of Fact (attached) will need to be adopted to comply w/the CZMA if Resolution 98-265 is adopted and urging restraint in the exercise of Council Rule No. 4.2(1) re removal procedures.

M 574, 1998 by: GREG KAI
Suggesting turning the Natatorium into a chlorinated water pool as a cheaper alternative to restoring it to a saltwater pool.

M 610, 1998 by: JEANNE COMER
Supporting a restored beachfront and suitable memorial for the Natatorium area and recounting past problems with the Natatorium.

M 1514, 1998 by: RICK BERNSTEIN
Submitting excerpts from various articles re E. coli outbreaks.

M 1628, 1998 by: RICK BERNSTEIN
KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
Submitting comments re the Natatorium pool.

M 1729, 1998 by: MICHAEL J. GOTT
DISABLED AMERICAN VETERANS
Supporting full restoration of the Natatorium.

M 1731, 1998 by: PEGGY M. HOEFER
Supporting passage of Resolution 98-265.

M 1738, 1998 by: LINUCE C. PANG
FRIENDS OF THE NATATORIUM
Supporting Resolution.

M 1739, 1998 by: NANCY BANNICK
FRIENDS OF THE NATATORIUM
Supporting Resolution.

M 1740, 1998 by: AILEEN M. NIELSEN
Supporting Resolution.

M 1741, 1998 by: JOHN F. NIELSEN
Supporting Resolution.

M 1742, 1998 by: MARY LEINEWEBER
Supporting Resolution.

M 1743, 1998 by: LISA LEBONTE
Supporting Resolution.

M 1744, 1998 by: WILLIAM "BUZZ" HONG
HAWAII BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION TRADES COUNCIL
Supporting Resolution.

M 1745, 1998 by: BEVERLY D. MAJOR
Supporting Resolution.

M 1746, 1998 by: JOANN S. MIYAGAWA
Supporting Resolution.

M 1747, 1998 by: ELIZABETH A. SCHALLER
STATE DEPT. OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
Providing information re the applicability of Chapter 11-13A, Hawaii Adminstrative Rules re public swimming pools, to the Waikiki War Memorial Natatorium.

M 1748, 1998 by: RICK BERNSTEIN
KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
Enclosing The Atlanta Journal Constitution articles re the Summer 1998 E. coli breakout at the White Water Park in Marietta, Georgia.

M 1749, 1998 by: JOAN HOLUP
Supporting restoration of the arch.

M 1750, 1998 by: MICHELLE SPALDING MATSON
Supporting Resolution.

M 1751, 1998 by: KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
Submitting two schemes for the creation of a Waikiki War Memorial Beach.

M 1753, 1998 by: DAVID SCOTT
HISTORIC HAWAII FOUNDATION
Supporting full restoration of the Natatorium. (same as M-1765)

M 1754, 1998 by: ROBERT N. KATAYAMA
Supporting Resolution.

M 1755, 1998 by: FRED ROHLFING
Supporting Resolution.

M 1760, 1998 by: S. K. MCMURDO
THE RETIRED OFFICERS ASSOCIATION
Supporting complete restoration of the Natatorium.

M 1761, 1998 by: JOANN S. MIYAGAWA
Supporting Resolution.

M 1762, 1998 by: SAMUEL JAMES FREAS
INTL. SWIMMING HALL OF FAME
Supporting Resolution.

M 1765, 1998 by: DAVID SCOTT
HISTORIC HAWAII FOUNDATION
Supporting full restoration of the Natatorium. (same as M-1753)

M 1766, 1998 by: JOHN M. SHUBERT
Opposing reconstruction of the pool.

M 1767, 1998 by: RICK BERNSTEIN
KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
11/24/98 Star-Bulletin Letter to the Editor titled "It's folly to restore decrepit Natatorium" by Rick Bernstein.

M 1768, 1998 by: MICHELLE SPALDING MATSON
Supporting restoration.

M 1769, 1998 by: CHARLES FLETCHER
Listing concerns re the restoration design.

M 1770, 1998 by: CHARLES FLETCHER
Forwarding letter from Kevin R. Bodge of Olsen Associates, Inc., discussing concerns re the proposed design and attaching Mr. Bodge's curriculum vitae.

M 1771, 1998 by: NORMAN GOLDSTEIN
HAWAII MEDICAL JOURNAL
Submitting copy of excerpt from 04/89 "Portraits in Paradise" television program.

M 1772, 1998 by: FRED TRASK
Opposing full restoration but supporting a partial restoration.

M 1773, 1998 by: YOSHIHIKO SUGAHARA
Supporting project.

M 1774, 1998 by: ROBERT FREITAS
MILITARY ORDER OF THE PURPLE HEART
Supporting full restoration.

M 1775, 1998 by: D. GARY LATTIMER
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1776, 1998 by: MARK MOSES
STATE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Supporting preservation.

M 1777, 1998 by: JAMES AND LILA MORGAN
Supporting partial restoration of the memorial.

M 1778, 1998 by: DICK PERRINE
Opposing full restoration.

M 1779, 1998 by: M. MCCORD
Opposing the Natatorium.

M 1780, 1998 by: R. L. BEALL
BEALL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
Supporting restoration.

M 1786, 1998 by: RALPH PORTMORE
HISTORIC HAWAII FOUNDATION
Supporting restoration.

M 1788, 1998 by: JEANNE B. COMER
Opposing full restoration.

M 1789, 1998 by: M. CRISTOFORI & G. LIZENBERY
Opposing restoration of pool.

M 1790, 1998 by: HENRY CURTIS
LIFE OF THE LAND
Commenting on the Attorney General's statement that the Natatorium didn't meet the state definition of a swimming pool.

M 1791, 1998 by: ANNA KERR
Opposing restoration of the swimming pool.

M 1793, 1998 by: JAMES K. ANDERSON
Supporting Resolution.

M 1794, 1998 by: JAMES C. BEAMAN
Opposing restoration of the pool.

M 1795, 1998 by: RICK BERNSTEIN
KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
Opposing full restoration.

M 1796, 1998 by: EARL TENN
Supporting restoration of the Natatorium on behalf of himself and Mrs. Duke Kahanamoku.

M 1799, 1998 by: ROBERT FREITAS
MILITARY ORDER OF THE PURPLE HEART
Supproting full restoration.

M 1801, 1998 by: LINDA ENGELBERG
KAIMANA BEACH COALITION
Opposing Natatorium.

M 1807, 1998 by: A. P. AND FLORENCE B. LEY
Opposing project.

M 1808, 1998 by: FRED TRASK
Opposing restoration.

M 1809, 1998 by: H. DOUGLAS MIKI
Opposing restoration.

M 1812, 1998 by: LINDA RODDY
Opposing full restoration.

M 1813, 1998 by: JOHN HARRISON
UHM ENVIROMENTAL CENTER
Opposing the Attorney General's statement that the Natatorium pool does not fall under the purview of the Dept. of Health.

M 1814, 1998 by: MARY-JANE MCMURDO
Supporting restoration.

M 1815, 1998 by: JAMES F. CARTWRIGHT
Opposing full restoration.

M 1816, 1998 by: ERIC N. HILL
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1817, 1998 by: JODIE PANG
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1818, 1998 by: LISA STEINDLER
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1819, 1998 by: JOHN TITCHEN
Listing questions re the Natatorium.

M 1821, 1998 by: LEW METELIZ
Opposing full restoration.

M 1822, 1998 by: MICHAEL ZUCKER
Opposing restoration.

M 1823, 1998 by: KENT BENNETT
Suggesting that the war memorial swimming pool be moved to the parking lot fronting Aloha Tower.

M 1824, 1998 by: ANNE SUNG BERNSTEIN
Opposing restoration of the pool.

M 1825, 1998 by: STUART COLEMAN
Opposing full restoration.

M 1826, 1998 by: HEATHER NAPELA WILLIAMS
Opposing restoration.

M 1827, 1998 by: GABRIELLE HAMMOND
Opposing restoration.

M 1828, 1998 by: LAEL NOELANI WEYENBERG
Supporting restoration of the arch.

M 1829, 1998 by: BRUCE ANDERSON
STATE HEALTH DEPT.
Urging the Mayor and others to carefully consider health and safety issues related to the Natatorium.

M 1830, 1998 by: MICHELLE SPALDING MATSON
Supporting restoration.

M 1831, 1998 by: EARL TENN
Supporting restoration.

M 1832, 1998 by: LOIS KIEHL-CAIN
Opposing restoration.

M 1833, 1998 by: DAPHNE THEOTOCATOS
Opposing restoration.

M 1834, 1998 by: BUZZ HONG
HI BUILDING AND CONST. TRADES COUNCIL
Supporting restoration.

M 1835, 1998 by: VERNON MINER
M 1836, 1998 by: SYLVIA WILD
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1837, 1998 by: ROGER LUKAS
Opposing full restoration.

M 1838, 1998 by: LOUIS XIGOGIANIS
Supporting full restoration.

M 1839, 1998 by: S. PEPE
Supporting project.

M 1840, 1998 by: GEORGE DOWNING
Opposing full restoration.

M 1841, 1998 by: CHARLES FLETCHER
Discussing concerns re the natatorium restoration design w/regard to the sedimentation and circulation characteristics of the area.

M 1842, 1998 by: KAPIOLANI PARK PRESERVATION SOCIETY
Supporting the granting of am SMP for the rehabilitation of the Natatorium.

M 1843, 1998 by: PATRICK DOYLE
Supporting restoration.

M 1844, 1998 by: LINZIE CONNALLY
Supporting restoration.

M 1845, 1998 by: JOAN SHEERAN APO
Supporting restoration.

M 1846, 1998 by: EDWARD SMITH
Supporting restoration.

M 1847, 1998 by: KATHERINE NAPOLEON
Supporting full restoration.

M 1848, 1998 by: ROGER LEE
Supporting restoration.

M 1849, 1998 by: LOUIS HERMAN
Opposing restoration.

M 1850, 1998 by: RICHARD D. GRONNA
Opposing restoration.

M 1899, 1998 by: WILLIAM TAM
Supporting partial restoration.

M 1900, 1998 by: VERNON MINER
Supporting a restored arch and expansion of the beach.

M 1901, 1998 by: JIMMY CHONG
10/15/97 Honolulu Star-Bulletin editorial entitled "Council should stand firm on Natatorium."

M 1902, 1998 by: JADE YOUNG
Opposing the commercialization of the Kaimana Beach area.

M 1903, 1998 by: BRUCE ANDERSON
STATE HEALTH DEPT.
Urging the Mayor and others to carefull consider the health and safety issues raised re the Natatorium.

M 1904, 1998 by: UNSIGNED
M 1905, 1998 by: ROGER S. FUJIOKA
UHM WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH CENTER
Submitting an assessment of the concerns for water borne diseases at the Natatorium and a proposed action for the Natatorium.

M 1970, 1998 by: JOHN H. SMITH
Opposing a swimming pool at Waikiki Beach (but supporting rentention of the memorial archway).

M 1973, 1998 by: JANNY PASTORE & LYMAN BLANK
Expressing concern re possible cost overruns if the Natatorium is restored; and attaching additional concerns and a 11/28/98 The Honolulu Advertiser article entitled "Chinatown work 45% over budget" by William Kresnak.

P 26, 1998 by: VIVIEN LOUIS- WILLIAMS
Supporting SMP/SV. (99 signatures/cards)

P 28, 1998 by: ANNIE H. USUI, ET AL.
Opposing project.

P 29, 1998 by: CHRISTINE BERKMANN, ET AL.
UHM WOMEN'S SWIMMING & DIVING TEAM
Supporting restoration.

P 30, 1998 by: BILLY CLARATY, ET AL.
UHM MEN'S SWIMMING & DIVING TEAM
Supporting restoration.

P 31, 1998 by: AMY E. UHECHI, ET AL.
Opposing full restoration but supporting the creation of a new beach and restoration of the memorial arch.

P 32, 1998 by: DAVID WRIGHT, ET AL.
Supporting the creation of a new beach and restoration of the memorial arch.

---

Bills and Resolutions